Page 1 of 1
optics poll
Posted: Fri Jul 01, 2011 12:40 pm
by Adaan
A list of pecking order of brands and lines within brands, gleaned from feedback of customers and members of their forum - Copied verbatim from
http://www.opticstalk.com/
The scale below was formed by SWFA sales staff, customer service, pro-staff and owners using personal experience, customer input and facts supplied by the manufacturers. The ranking system is based on the following criteria.
51% Optical Quality - How bright and clear the scope is.
15% Specifications - Field of view, eye relief, weight, adjustment travel, etc.
15% Durability - How do they with stand the test of time.
12% Special Features & Options - Proprietary items (reticles, design, turrets), Zoom ratio.
7% Warranty & Customer Service - How good are they.
0% Value - Bang for your buck. This criteria has been removed due to O.T. member input.
In order to maintain the scale's simplicity we are not listing every single manufacture and only major manufactures will have several of their brands listed. This scale also does not have discontinued brands or products like the old U.S.A. made Redfields, Japan Tasco or Japan Simmons Aetec. This scale is heavily weighted toward HUNTING as being the application the scope will be used for.
This scale will be kept current with changes that the manufacturers are making that affect their rank. Many of the lower end companies have been bought and sold a lot recently and while the names have stayed the same......the product has not.
2009 Riflescope Rating Scale:
Leica ER, Swarovski Z6, Zeiss Victory
Kahles C - CL & CSX, Premier Reticle, Schmidt & Bender
Kahles KX, U.S. Optics, Swarovski PH & American Lightweight
Bushnell Elite 6500, Leupold VX-7, Nightforce NXS, IOR Valdada, Vortex Razor
Bushnell Elite 4200, Leupold VX-3, Nikon Monarch & Monarch X, Zeiss Conquest
Leupold Mark 4 VX III & VX-L, Meopta, Nikon Monarch Gold & Titanium, Sightron SIII & S2 Big Sky, Vortex Viper
Burris Black Diamond Signature Select XTR & Euro Diamond, Pentax Lightseeker, Trijicon Accupoint, Weaver Grand Slam
Bushnell Elite 3200, Leupold VX-II, Millet Tactical/Buck Gold, Nikko Stirling, Nikon Buckmaster, Sightron SI & SII, Vortex Crossfire & Diamondback, Super Sniper Fixed
Burris Fullfield II & Timberline, Leupold Rifleman & VX-I, Leatherwood, Mueller, Nikon ProStaff, Simmons
Barska, Sightmark, Swift, Truglo
BSA, Tasco, Yukon
ATN, Leapers, NcStar
Re: optics poll
Posted: Fri Jul 01, 2011 1:37 pm
by rednat
Adaan
het jy miskien 'n idee hoe die optical quality getoets is??
Re: optics poll
Posted: Fri Jul 01, 2011 1:54 pm
by Adaan
Rednat
Ongelukkig nie
Re: optics poll
Posted: Fri Jul 01, 2011 2:24 pm
by rednat
Adaan
Die volgende is aan my per e-pos gestuur deur 'n forumlid wat voel dat ons huidige maniere van teleskope toets nog te lukraak is vir sy behoefte en tevredenheid. Volgens hom is daar dus wel wetenskaplike metodes om met groter korrektheid te evalueer en die rol van die menslik be?nvloedbare oordeel te verminder.
Recently I read a review in GUNTESTS and found they actually use a photo meter to test brightness. Now this is more accurate and objective than looking through scopes with human eyes. And it clarifies the myth that Burris is brighter. Let's not forget Burris is bigger and heavier too. Here is how they test for brightness:
"Brightness. We put the scopes in a darkened room 20 feet away from a pure-white frosted, backlit screen to minimize hotspots. We aimed a 55-mm Nikkor micro (close focusing) lens attached to a Nikon 8008S camera (with the light meter set on center weighted) through each scope and focused it on the crosshair and centered the crosshair in the viewfinder. We then set the camera?s light meter at 1/8 second and began stopping the lens down until we reached what the camera indicated was a properly exposed setting.
Our testers thought the Leupold?s brightness was on par with the Burris and Bausch & Lomb scopes, and was slightly better than the Redfield in our test group. It is crisp edge to edge, and shooters could easily read 1-inch type at 50 yards on the 12X setting. The recoil test showed no apparent changes in the scope?s tracking. Parallax was not a problem."
Nogal interressant --- lyk amper of die boeremaniere van teleskope toets deur tegnologie bedreig mag word.
Re: optics poll
Posted: Fri Jul 01, 2011 4:25 pm
by baboonstalker
Wat hier getoets word is hoeveel lig die scope deurlaat en sal 'n indikasie gee van hoe goed hy potensieel in swak lig sal vaar. (minder lense en beter coatings sal beter "brightness/ hederheid" gee)
Die optiese kwaliteit (hoe goed die lense geslyp is) word egter nie getoets nie en definisie (of hoe skerp die beeld is) word gladnie getoets nie.
Laasgenoemde sal vir enige dag of kompetiesie skut van meer waarde wees. Nag of skemer jagters wil die beste van altwee h? (helderheid en definisie)
Re: optics poll
Posted: Fri Jul 01, 2011 7:39 pm
by rednat
BS
Sou mens dit konsekwent kon toets op 'n basis van vergelyking.
Re: optics poll
Posted: Sat Jul 02, 2011 12:16 am
by baboonstalker
Rednat,
Om die optiese kwaliteit van die lense tussen verskillende teleskope te vergelyk kan jy 'n optiese kaart gebruik soos die wat oogkundiges gebruik om te sien hoeveel definisie jy met elke teleskoop oor dieselfde afstand kan uitmaak. die toets gaan egter die toetser se oe? ook toets en is slegs bruikbaar om twee of meer teleskope onder dieselfde toestand met mekaar te vergelyk.
Daar is waarskynlik ook optiese instrumente beskikbaar wat vir die doel gebruik kan word, maar ek is nie bekend daarmee nie.
Re: optics poll
Posted: Sat Jul 02, 2011 10:45 am
by bullseye
More Manne
Ek wonder of optiese kwaliteit regtig die eerste preoriteit moet wees, ek gee toe dit is belangrik. Vir my is "durability" meer belangrik bedoelende die kruis moet kan bly daar waar dit gestel is, en moet kan stel en terug stel presies op sy merke. Dit sou interresant gewees het wat die scopes se rangorde dan sou wees .
Dit sal n reuse sprong in die regte rigting wees as teleskope wetenskaplik oor dieselfde kam geskeer kan word en die mens faktor uitgelaat word.
lekker topic
groete
Ben.
Re: optics poll
Posted: Sat Jul 02, 2011 11:37 am
by tafjak
Ben Brand
Ja, daar is seker 'n paar goete wat 'n scope goed maak. Soos jy reeds ges? het, is "duralbility" ene, helderheid, verstellings, betroubaarheid en natuurlik die prys daarvan. Dit help nie betroubaarheid is aanvanklik goed nie, dit moet deur die lewe van die scope of gebruiker betroubaar wees. Dieselfde geld dan vir al die eienskappe.
Hier gaan so hier en daar versklle wees van die gebruikers, maar dit is klein in vergelyking met die scope se eienskappe. Kyk maar wat bly lank op die geweer, gewoonlik goeie aanduiding wat werk. Met die vinnig groeiende verbeterings en tegnologie, is daar wat tog agterbly, gewoonlik op "clarity" en kruishare. So dit is raadsaam om die die scope se "performance" eers te check voordat jy enige besluite neem.
Make/fabrikate wat nogal die tyd staan is na my mening en ondervinding die manne wat hul eie fabrieke het. Gewoonlik het die "Brands" wie nie eie fabriek het nie, 'n nice scope, maar kan nie die waarborg dra nie, want die spesifieke model is net vir ruk beskikbaar voordat almal die model aangekoop het en verstellings aan die eienskappe gemaak het. "Brands" soos Nikon, Lynx ens. kan vir sekere tyd die model waarborg(gewoonlik ruil hulle dit net om) en dan is dit "discontinued" en word sulke modelle met sogenaamde "nuwer"/beter modelle omgeruil of die kli?nt moet by betaal om beter te kry. Ja, ek gaan nou redelike teenkanting kry met die stelling, maar laat dit maar kom.
ONLY THE VERY RICH CAN AFFORD A CHEAP SCOPE! Finish en Klaar.
Mooiloop
Re: optics poll
Posted: Sat Jul 02, 2011 11:54 am
by tafjak
Ben Brand
O ja! Hier is 'n man op my tuisdorp wat nou al vir die laaste 9jaar gereeld tussen scopes rondval. Het die geld maar wil nou net om die dood nie iets ordentliks koop nie. Glo te duur, maar in sy 9jaar het hy nou al meer betaal aan diesel, telefoonoproepe, gekwesde bokke, rooigesigsindroom, scopes en fieterjasies dat my ou scopie 'n "steel" was.
Re: optics poll
Posted: Sat Jul 02, 2011 2:31 pm
by muishond
Goeie dag
Volgens Adaan se inset plaas hulle die Bushnell Elite 6500 bo Meopta , maar ek weet dat die Meopta Meostar R1 4-16x 44 duurder is as die 2.5-16 x 50 Bushnell Elite 6500.
Kan iemand my hier dalk help ?
Groete
Muishond
Re: optics poll
Posted: Sun Jul 03, 2011 9:46 am
by rednat
Nou moet ons seker net nie die DOEL waarvoor die scope benodig word miskyk nie.
By taktiese scopes vind ek die akkurate gestellery ( hierdie vierkant tegniek om weer te kom waar jy was)
sekerlik noodsaaklik want op die baan stel jy vir afstand, wind ens. -- ekself mik meeste van die tyd sommer op of af of gee effens toe -- alles moet nie te akkuraat wees nie want dan kompenseer niks vir my bewery nie.
Vir my jagscopes vind ek die gestellery werklik van geen nut of praktiese betekenis -- is dit sommer net 'n foefie ----- Daar soek ek 'n scope wat jy instel en dan is dit 'n fixture vir die toekoms. Ek stel nie in die jagveld nie -- die bokke wat ek probeer skiet is nie vasgemaak nie. So ek soek 'n scope waarmee ek goed kan sien en wat
aanhou skiet waar hy ingestel is.
Taffie ,
Kyk maar wat bly lank op die geweer, gewoonlik goeie aanduiding wat werk.
---- ja ek stem saam.
Ek het twee make scopes wat nou al baie jare op gewere is en nog nooit weer na die eerste instel 'n instel nodig gehad het nie -- groepeer nog gemaklik 5 skote binne 1 duim. En dit is my Zeisse en Proffesional Lynxe en ek oorweeg nie om hulle te vervang nie.
Re: optics poll
Posted: Sun Jul 03, 2011 11:49 am
by tafjak
rednat
Vir my jagscopes vind ek die gestellery werklik van geen nut of praktiese betekenis -- is dit sommer net 'n foefie ----- Daar soek ek 'n scope wat jy instel en dan is dit 'n fixture vir die toekoms.
O, nou hoekom is dit 'n foefie, m.a.w. dat 'n scope nie eerlik kan stel nie? Ek glo dit is van die goeie eienskappe in 'n scope. Gestel jy weet dat die scope 30- of 50mm hoog op 100meter skiet en dit graag wil afstel na zero op 100meter in die jagveld. Veral by springbokvoorsit jag om dat die skietafstand naby is en presiese skote geskiet moet word. Almal het nie 10gewere nie en moet maar van 'n slegste saak die beste maak, as jy dit sleg kan noem.
Mooiloop
Re: optics poll
Posted: Sun Jul 03, 2011 12:45 pm
by DSBW
Taffie
Jou opsomming oor teleskope, fabrikate wat hul eie vervaardiging behartig en wat bly lank op 'n geweer is baie goed gestel. Deesdae is dit amper onmoontlik om die kaf van die koring te skei as ons net sou kyk na beeldgehalte, verstellings ensovoorts. Vir my is die beste aanduiding van kwaliteit nog steeds die produkte wat oor meer as een leeftyd reeds in die mark is, en nie noodwendig die "market trends" volg nie, eerder die pas aangee met relevante kwaliteit produkte.
Dawie
Re: optics poll
Posted: Sun Jul 03, 2011 1:14 pm
by tafjak
Dawie
Jy jag al 'n paar dae in jou lewe(dit is nie hoe oud jy is nie, maar hoe oud/lank in die jagveld/omstandighede wat tel) en 'n mens let op na wat op die gewere is wat by jou aankom. Gewoonlik onthou jy nogal die suksesse van verskillende gewere en scopes dienooreenkomstig van die skut/jagter.
Ek glo nogsteeds aan die ou Hitler en sy buurmanne, vat gewoonlik nie nonsens nie en kan eerlik sulke fabrikate aanbeveel. Hier en daar nie so baie te kies nie, hang maar af wat jy soek en wil gebruik. Gewoonlik word hierdie tipe scopes opgesit en bly ook dan op!
Mooiloop
Re: optics poll
Posted: Sun Jul 03, 2011 5:15 pm
by rednat
So is dit.
Daar word duidelik op verskillende maniere gejag en ons neem kennis. Party jagters gebruik selfs rangefinders op 100.
Ek het nog nooit as 'n bok op 100 tree staan dit nodig gevind om my teleskoop af te stel nie. Zero op 200 en met die vinnige kalibers skiet ons 1.5 duim hoog op 100 -- geen probleem dus met kopskootjies nie en stel dan beslis nie vir die 1.5 duim aan teleskoop in die jagveld nie.
Re: optics poll
Posted: Sun Jul 03, 2011 7:04 pm
by tafjak
rednat
rednat wrote:
So is dit.
Daar word duidelik op verskillende maniere gejag en ons neem kennis. Party jagters gebruik selfs rangefinders op 100.
Ek het nog nooit as 'n bok op 100 tree staan dit nodig gevind om my teleskoop af te stel nie. Zero op 200 en met die vinnige kalibers skiet ons 1.5 duim hoog op 100 -- geen probleem dus met kopskootjies nie en stel dan beslis nie vir die 1.5 duim aan teleskoop in die jagveld nie.
............ja, ja ou korrelkop!
Re: optics poll
Posted: Mon Jul 04, 2011 12:47 am
by klipspringer
Hello Manne
As jy die ketting van geweer, ammunisie, teleskoop, montering, en skietkuns breek .... gaan jy erens die prys betaal. Die kortpad lei jou weer terug na die begin.
Groete
Jan
Re: optics poll
Posted: Mon Jul 04, 2011 7:50 am
by rednat
Baboonstalker
Jou vorige kommentare verwys. Lyk my jy ken van dit.
Wat s? jy van die volgende.
Som dit asb. uit hoofde van jou spesifieke kennis vir ons kortliks op sodat ons gewone ouens dit beter kan verstaan en voeg so bietjie waarde by -- miskien kry ons iewers 'n vergelykende riglyn.
LET VERAL OP DIE LAASTE PARAGRAAF WAT DAAROP WIL DUI DAT DIE MENSLIKE TOETS VAN PERSOON TOT PERSOON MAG VERSKIL????
Scope & Spotting Scope Resolution and Magnification
Eyesight Resolution Limits
The normal or median human visual resolution limit is 1 MOA (minute of angle). This is also called normal visual acuity when use by your eye doctor. On the typical Snellen eye chart, the 20/20 line (20 foot line in USA) or 6/6 line (6 meters in the rest of the world) was designed to be readable with a visual resolution or acuity of 1 MOA. The other lines/characters are scaled accordingly.
Telescopes were developed as visual aids to overcome this limited visual resolution or acuity. The principal tool for resolution improvement is magnification. It is obvious that magnification increases the apparent size of objects. However and more importantly magnification increases visual resolution. In the following illustration note how even small (doublings ? powers of 2) increases in magnification greatly increase our ability to resolve (distinguish) small but important details by both increasing their apparent size and making better use of the available field of view.
Fred Bohl, 10 June 2007 Page 1 of 6
Scope & Spotting Scope Resolution and Magnification
Scope Resolution Limits
Diffraction Limited Optics A long historical record holds that diffraction defines the ultimate resolution limit of telescopes. Generally we can say that any aperture with a finite size will cause diffraction and hence its resolution will be limited. The finite aperture (front lens, main mirror) must cut off a part of the incoming plane wave front. This missing part is disturbing the otherwise perfect interference of the propagating waves in a certain way. The result is a modulation of the wave front called the Point Spread Function (PSF). Instead of the perfect image of a point this PSF (for an otherwise perfect telescope!) creates something like pictured below (when sliced in the center of this 3-dimensional shape):
The Airy Disk for a perfect and unobstructed telescope is encircling 84% of the energy from the point light source. 16% are spread to the rings with the first ring containing the biggest part. A telescope with such a perfect Airy Disk is also said to have a Strehl Ratio of 100%. Because of possible aberrations (i.e. Spherical aberration, Coma, Astigmatism, Chromatic aberration) and other things like wrong focus, central obstruction and spider vanes a real life's telescope has a Strehl Ratio of less than 100%.
Somewhat arbitrarily a telescope with a Strehl Ratio less than 80% is said to be diffraction limited. This is corresponding to a resulting wave front error of ?/4. Fred Bohl, 10 June 2007 Page 2 of 6
Scope & Spotting Scope Resolution and Magnification
Estimating the Resolution Limit: Airy, Rayleigh and Dawes Obviously the resolution limit or resolving power is connected to that Airy Disk, because no detail imaged by the telescope can be smaller than this disk. The radius of the Airy Disk can be estimated with: R = 0.2516 * ? / D (for angular resolving in arc sec) The Airy Disk is getting smaller when the diameter of the aperture is getting bigger. On the other hand the Airy Disk is shrinking with smaller wavelengths. Blue light is resolving better than red light. Because of the human eye being most sensitive to green light the wavelength of 550 nm is very often picked for the calculations. Rayleigh's Resolution Limit Lord Rayleigh said that the ultimate resolution limit of a telescope is reached when the center of one Airy Disk is just one radius away of the other one.
Rayleigh's resolution limit [arc sec] = 138.4 / Aperture Diameter [mm] (for green light) Dawes Resolution Limit Dawes found out by his own observations that he could resolve a binary star with both stars having a magnitude of 6 slightly better than Lord Rayleigh claimed. The Dawes limit is hence an empirical one and can be written as: Dawes's resolution limit [arc sec] = 116 / Aperture Diameter [mm] (for green light)
Or more usefully to rifle scopes and spotting scopes
Dawes's resolution limit [MOA] = 1.933 / Objective Diameter [mm] (for green light)
There have been advances in large astronomic telescope optics, digital imaging and image processing and even adaptive optics (real-time computer assisted mirror shape corrections) to improve the useful resolution of big telescopes. However, for the current available scopes and spotting scopes the Dawes limit currently gives the best (supported by many observations) value for the best resolution that can be reasonably expected in shooting applications.
Fred Bohl, 10 June 2007 Page 3 of 6
Scope & Spotting Scope Resolution and Magnification
Example Images
The following images show photographs at the diffraction and Dawes Limit for a single point and a limiting close pair of points. The first pair show stars (white on black) and the second are the negative (black on off-white - like common match targets).
Data Table
These tables were calculated for popular sizes of objective lens diameters of the respective devices.
Scope Sights
Objective Diameter (mm)
24
32
40
42
45
50
52
56
Dawes Resolution Limit (MOA)
0.081
0.060
0.048
0.046
0.043
0.039
0.037
0.035
Match Magnification (x)
12.4
16.6
20.7
21.7
23.3
25.9
26.9
29.0
Spotting Scopes
Objective Diameter (mm)
60
70
80
85
90
100
125
130
Dawes Resolution Limit (MOA)
0.032
0.028
0.024
0.023
0.021
0.019
0.016
0.015
Match Magnification (x)
31.0
36.2
41.4
44.0
46.6
51.7
64.7
67.2
Match magnification means the Dawes Limit equals the magnified normal visual acuity of the human eye (1MOA). At less magnification the resolution is limited by the user's eye. Above this magnification the resolution is diffraction limited by the objective diameter to the Dawes Resolution Limit (MOA) above.
NOTE: Dawes Resolution Limit (inches) = Dawes Resolution Limit (MOA) x Range (yards) x 0.01047
Also = Smallest separation between features and minimum POA (point of aim) error (confusion circle)!
Fred Bohl, 10 June 2007 Page 4 of 6
Scope & Spotting Scope Resolution and Magnification
Magnification Limits
Magnifications greater than the match to Dawes Limit do not produce any more real resolution. However such greater magnifications do still help detail perception by reducing useless clutter in the field of view. For example, look at the 8x (top left) illustration on page 1. The magnification could be doubled again then still retain all important information and be easier to decipher do to reduction of irrelevant information in the field of view as shown below.
16x
Note that if viewed through a diffraction limited scope the edges of features of the target image would begin to blur and also show diffraction effects for those features below the Dawes resolution size (diameter or width) at greater than match magnifications. These effects have not been simulated above.
In the best real seeing conditions (clear still air, no mirage) and with no scope motion, maximum useable magnification will be about 400x for spotting scopes. For more typical range and field conditions, maximum useable magnification will be about 250x for spotting scopes.
Scope sights face practical constraints on size and weight such that maximum attainable magnification will be about 60x. Seeing conditions will also degrade the image quality for the scope sight.
Variable Magnification Scope Sights
The principle advantage of a variable versus a fixed magnification scope sight is the ability to set a low magnification to acquire your target then raise the magnification to increase the aiming point resolution. Care must be taken to not to substitute the low magnification scope setting for target searching with binoculars in hunting situations (pointing the scope is also pointing the loaded firearm). Never move the point of aim outside the original field of view (know what your pointing the firearm at ? always).
Many prairie dog shooters and even some target shooters use a variable to decrease the power to minimize or at least manage the amount of mirage (optical distortion cause differential heating of the air in the field of view causing apparent motion ? often aggravated by wind). What they are doing is reducing the apparent magnitude of this motion by increasing the size of the field of view. The effect is still there but not as easily visible. While in extreme cases this may be necessary, it is being done at the expense of some effective resolution (aiming error increase) by adding clutter to the image field. This must be done with care and is of very dubious value for target shooting (learn to read the mirage as well as the wind).
Fred Bohl, 10 June 2007 Page 5 of 6
Scope & Spotting Scope Resolution and Magnification
Fred Bohl, 10 June 2007 Page 6 of 6
Effective Resolution Enhancement
Fortunately we all have a magnificent image enhancement device (our brain) to help us utilize our hardware to its fullest capability. Our brain's ability at pattern recognition (to find a learned pattern within a complex visual field) is awesome. An example is finding a familiar face in a crowd of strangers at an airport or stadium. The target case is much less complex and therefore can be done at much greater distances in a lower resolution data field. You know what your targets should look like, have looked at them at multiple ranges before, and are expecting to see them. As you bring your cross hairs to bear on your expected target your brain is able to concentrate its vast image processing capability and filter out the noise and clutter in the data stream from your eyes. I firmly believe that you need to practice target acquisition and recognition just as all other aspects of the shooting sequence. Those that do will always be able to demonstrate far better working resolution/acuity on familiar targets than those that don't practice. You will have much less trouble if you practice using the same optics and targets as you will shoot in matches. It also helps to practice target acquisition and recognition under a wide variety of atmospheric and illumination conditions. These stored images ease the burden on the brain's image analysis system to find your desired POA among the noise and clutter providing for an enhanced "effective resolution ".
Re: optics poll
Posted: Mon Jul 04, 2011 2:37 pm
by Wouter Roets
Hallo Adaan
Baie dankie vir hierdie stukkie. Dit is bitter interessant. Hier is name wat ek geensins iets van af weet nie. Interessant ek sien nie Z3 of 4 nie.
Groetnis
Wouter
Re: optics poll
Posted: Tue Jul 05, 2011 2:15 am
by Adaan
Wouter
Daar is verseker baie wat ons nie van weet nie !!
Wil net se dat die poll in 2009 gedoen is ,so dinge kan dalk nou anders lyk!
Groete Adaan
Re: optics poll
Posted: Tue Jul 05, 2011 3:43 pm
by raychell
Wouter
in 2009
was die Z3, en Z4 die AV en die PH onderskydelik genoem
Raynie