Hier is een artikel.........
http://www.noseweek.co.za/print_article ... ticle=2453 28/02/2011 11:29
The Big Clean
Issue # 137 -March 2011
O what a tangled web we weave, when first we practise to deceive, wrote Sir
Walter Scott. He could have been referring to the recent stand-off between
environmentalists and provincial MECs and their farming-community constituents in
the war against indigenous free-ranging predators on livestock farms, that are
being blamed for a total onslaught against livestock.
The fine balance to our biodiversity means that if one predator is exterminated, the
next up the pecking order will take over. Their solution is to exterminate the lot ?
the consequences can be dealt with later. What counts is the livestock-farmers?
vote.
It all started with a survey by
some students (?Van Niekerk et
al?) at the University of the
Free State ? conducted
telephonically. The problem
arose when Professor H O de
Waal of the African Large
Predator Research Unit in the
Faculty of Natural and
Agricultural Sciences sent it to
the agriculture ministry, typed
up in a format typically used to
represent a published paper ?
which explains why it was not
quoted as a paper ?in prep?.
As Rob Harrison-White, who has 12 years? experience in Jackal/Predator Research,
pointed out: if such a survey is used to motivate government decisions that could
have serious implications for wildlife and livestock farmers, then it should be
available for perusal and comment by all. Publication of scientific data is then
subject to a rigorous peer review process. Anything less constitutes opinion
masquerading as fact.
He found this opinion poll to be of great interest as it contradicted other published
papers which showed, inter alia, that the state of health of sheep and the lack of
sheep husbandry was a major factor leading to predation and livestock mortalities.
Because the survey was being used to motivate protocols that would have
Page 1 of 3
http://www.noseweek.co.za/print_article ... ticle=2453 28/02/2011 11:29
significant implications for all South Africans, Harrison-White asked for access to
the claimed scientific study, or to see the peer-reviewed data ? which the good
professor has, to date, refused to provide.
Meanwhile, it was open war in the Western Cape after the conservation NGO,
Landmark Foundation, discovered that pressure was being applied to Cape Nature
staff by Agri Western Cape (AWC) ? through the MEC for Agriculture, Gerrit van
Rensburg ? to issue blanket destruction permits for predators in some farming
districts. These permits authorised the use of helicopters and night hunting; the
issuing of gin traps or other spring-loaded snares; dog-hunting and poison ?
irrespective of any ?collateral damage? to other species.
When Dr Bool Smuts, head of the Landmark Foundation, phoned AWC CEO Carl
Opperman, he was told they wished to ?clean up areas? so that normal agriculture
could continue. But Opperman could not answer basic questions as to what
numbers of predators they wished to exterminate or on what basis they had
determined that predators were indeed the cause of livestock farming difficulties.
He also refused to answer a written question regarding which law entitled his
organisation and the MEC to exert pressure on executive staff at Cape Nature to
issue permits against their better judgment and contrary to their policies and
procedures.
Smuts also asked that Landmark, which had locus standi (legal standing before a
court), be included in a proposed meeting with Cape Nature to discuss the issue,
but he got no response.
Next stop, Cape Nature, whose Lucille Meyer
said there had been ?no political pressure
exerted on the top management to issue
permits to destroy predators in the province in
a wholesale way. (By political pressure I mean
?you must do so or else??). Yes, our MECs
have in the past expressed particular views on
measures we should explore, based on
requests from landowners and farmers.?
Compare that to a written report from a
member of Cape Nature stating: ?We?ve been forced to approve permits for the use
of helicopters as tools to exterminate predators in certain Great Karoo areas? and,
?Yes, political pressure has certainly been brought to bear on us ? and in no
uncertain way.?
Page 2 of 3
http://www.noseweek.co.za/print_article ... ticle=2453 28/02/2011 11:29
Exit MEC Gerrit van Rensburg, whose staff member Johan Coetzee promptly
informed Smuts that the matter would henceforth be attended to by MEC Anton
Bredell (see noses132; 134; 135). It didn?t take long before Bredell bowed out,
indicating that future correspondence should be directed to Cape Nature
Conservation.
Is this what we are to expect from the DA?s promise of ?accountable and
transparent governance??
Smuts felt he had no alternative but to appeal to Premier Helen Zille for a meeting
in order to present written evidence about two of her cabinet ministers? ?unlawfully
trying to pressure statutory institutions to issue permits that not only ran contrary
to their policies and procedures, but also the law that the province was responsible
for implementing?.
The eventual response was that they could not grant his request for an interview
until they had heard from the MECs about Smuts?s allegations. This was despite
written confirmation from Cape Nature staff of the minister?s ultra vires actions
(beyond his powers). Were they thus suggesting that the MECs investigate
themselves?
When Cape Talk and Radio 702 got involved, there was some hasty damage
control as Bredell was asked to explain their actions on air.
Now, pre-election, there appears to be a back-down by the DA administration in the
Western Cape: permits are not being issued and a task team has been appointed to
investigate further.
Says Smuts: ?We can only hope this team comprises all relevant stakeholders and
does not degenerate ? as so often happens in this industry ? into an exclusive club
that determines the outcome, regardless of the data before them.?
Meanwhile, the plot thickens: the Department of Environmental Affairs and
Tourism tried to exclude environmentalists from a public-consultation Leopard
Management Workshop: the list of those invited is heavily biased in favour of
hunting interests. But that?s another story?
Page 3 of 3