Nikon toetsing

User avatar
Jagtersdok
Global Moderator
Global Moderator
Posts: 2034
Joined: Wed Mar 03, 2010 8:10 pm

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by Jagtersdok »

raychell wrote: maar sal dieselfde bok lank genoeg stilstaan om met verskillende gewere op hom te mik
Ek glo nie daar is enige van ons wat 'n dier gaan skiet net om die scope te toets nie

Oom Chris se altyd "jy mount nie 'n Nightforce op 'n geweer nie jy mount die geweer onder die Nightforce"
Jong daar is wildsplase wat kampe het wat net vir wild besigtiging is. Wild is baie mak vir loop en voertuie en jy kan tot halfuur staan en kyk en onder boom gaan staan of in die oop pad.

Ja die Nightforce is maar swaar maar soos jy s? dit is gespesialiseerde scopes. Daar is vab die 50-56mm scopes wat nie so swaar is nie en jong vir party manne met die swakker o? help daai ekstra bietjie in die dag ook om die beeld bietjie beter te maak. Al kan ek en jy miskien nie die verskil agter kom nie
NEELS NIEMAND, CENTURION

Laat die roere dreun!
.243 Win Frankonia, .270 Win Musgrave
.303 Britt Lee Enfield, .375 Pre'64 Winchester Delux, .375 H&H P14Winchester, [308 Win Mauser & .222 Sako & .22Bruno waiting for liscences]
User avatar
Piet Breedt
Hero Member
Hero Member
Posts: 2275
Joined: Mon Mar 15, 2010 10:54 am

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by Piet Breedt »

Rednat, baie dankie vir jou objektiewe toets tussen die Nikon en Lynx van presies dieselfde groote. Ek het ongelukkig nie die geleentheid om hulle sy aan sy te toets, en  rapporteer maar net wat ek sien in dit wat ek moet toets. Jou waarnemings bevestig maar net wat ek vermoed oor die lens kwaliteit wat pryse bepaal.

Ek toets dit wat vir my gegee is, en gee my eerlikke opinie. Ek het geen belang daarin om enige iets anders te raporteer.

Raychell, ek het na my Nikon v?rkyker gekyk en gesien hy word in China gemaak, sowel as my Vortex v?rkyker. Dit lyk vir my dat daar regtig baie min optiese toerusting is wat vandag gemaak word in die fabriek wat se naam daarop is. Selfs die nuwe Burris teleskope word in die ek dink in die Fillipeine gemaak. So v?r ek weet word die Z3 - Z5 Swarovski ook in Amerika aanmekaargesit, om die kostes af te bring.

Onder op die betrokke Nikon teleskoop wat ek toets, staan daar "Made in Japan". Ek weet nie of hulle sekere modelle self vervaardig, maar dit lyk of hulle ook maar soos meeste ander "Brands" verskillende produkte by meer as een vervaardiger koop, of laat aanmekaar sit. Ek weet nie.

My taak was maar net bloot om die betrokke teleskoop te toets, en n eerlikke verslag daaroor te gee, maar dit ook langtermyn te doen. Onthou ook net dat elkeen van ons verskillende voorkeure het by kruishare, en vergrotings ens, maar dat ons almal se o? nie dieselfde is nie. Dit is wel vir my opmerklik dat ons ouer manne soos ek en Taffie die bietjie dikker kruishare verkies vir nagskiet, as die jong manne wie se o? nog goed is.

Soos met karre, sal ons almal nooit presies saamstem nie, maar dit is soos dit moet wees.
rednat

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by rednat »

Ons stem dus saam dat dit nie 'n vergelykende, geloofwaardige, verteenwoordigende, geldige of aanvaarbare toets vir 'n teleskoop of geweer is of behoort te wees om sommer maar net 'n bok te gaan doodskiet vir die doel nie. Let wel en dan is ons  sekerlik nie groen nie.

Taffie, Hoekom moes 'n rubriekskrywer nou juis in my teenwoordigheid of by myself hom daaraan skuldig gemaak het?? Ag nee dit is mos nou so 'n effense belaglike vragie -- jy lees darem seker ook ons voorste jag, skiet en geweer tydskrifte -- gaan verfris jou geheue en antwoord jou eie vragie.
User avatar
raychell
Sr. Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 414
Joined: Thu Dec 04, 2008 7:56 pm

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by raychell »

Piet
Soos met karre, sal ons almal nooit presies saamstem nie, maar dit is soos dit moet wees
Ek kyk Ignition op kanaal 265 en dieselfde karre word in verskillende lande as verkillende fabrikate verkoop !
Ek onthou iemand het hier op die forum genoem dat van die Europese make in die ooste aanmekaar gesit word ek sal graag meer daarvan wil hoor.Almal sal seker ook onthou dat S&B hulle 6x en 8x in Hongarye laat aanmekaar sit het wat het daarvan geword doen hulle dit nog steeds?
Raynie
One of the greatest delusions in the world is the hope that the evils in this world are to be cured by legislation. ? Thomas Reed
User avatar
Hein M.
Hero Member
Hero Member
Posts: 3887
Joined: Wed Mar 25, 2009 3:52 pm

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by Hein M. »

rednat wrote:
So van toets gepraat: jy weet sekere maniere van toets deur mense wat stories/kommentare/rubrieke skryf is werklik oneties, belaglik en lagwekkend. Ons vind so dikwels dat 'n teleskoop of geweer getoets moet word. Dan word 'n gratis doodmaak geleentheid by 'n jagplaas verkry met die voordeel van advertensieruimte -- en dan moet 'n bok doodgeskiet word om nou kwansuis die geweer of teleskoop te toets --- die geweer of teleskoop kon net so goed of selfs beter op 'n teiken getoets word.  As jy nou 'n koe?l wil toets dan is dit iets anders -- ek weet egter van geen geweer of teleskoop wat beter op 'n bok getoets kan word as op 'n skietbaan nie. Van ons skrywers in van ons voorste jag en geweer tydskrifte maak hulle gereeld hieraan skuldig -- ook 'n soort van soustrein???
Rednat

Dalk weet jy waarvan ek praat, maar ek het baie onlangs die selfde idee gekry toe ek 'n evaluasie van 'n teleskoop in 'n baie bekende jagterstydskrif gelees het.  Die agtergrond was ook pesies soos hier beskryf is.  Ek bedoel, na so 'n ou gunsie, HOE KAN JY DAN NOU IETS SLEG SKRYF VAN DIE SCOPIE  Ek het sommer daar en dan geloofwaardigheid verloor in die toetser en sy tydskrif...

Hein
Nie alles wat getel kan word, tel nie. En nie alles wat tel kan getel word nie. - Albert Einstein
rednat

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by rednat »

Hein
Ek sien jy verstaan en ontleed wat jy lees en skiet nie net jakkalse nie.
Verder dat etiek en respek as waardes deel van jou volwasse norme is.
Ek wil jou gelukwens met jou waagmoed om ook aan hierdie saak te roer en te verklaar dat jy dit ook afkeur -- ons behoort almal hierdie sogenaamde evalueringmetode as 'n gebaar van disrespekvolle onetiese optrede te verwerp en nie sondermeer op die verdediging te reageer nie.
Ja Hein, En dit was ook nie die eerste keer nie !!
En dan word eties jag en respek vir die dier en 'n traan wat na die doodskiet gestort word onder my neus gevryf in dieselfde tydskrif!!
Dankie dat hierdie situasie jou ook hinder.
Last edited by rednat on Sun Jun 26, 2011 5:45 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Jaco Swart
Hero Member
Hero Member
Posts: 804
Joined: Tue Feb 16, 2010 1:50 pm

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by Jaco Swart »

Naand Manne.

Ek wil my kop ook in hierdie bynes insteek. Ek koop ook maandeliks al die jag en hengel tydskrifte wat uitkom. In die tydskrifte waar teleskope getoets word skryf die outeur gewoonlik dat hy die teleskoop gemonteer het , dit hom so paar skote gevat het om in te skiet en dan gaan jag hy 'n bok. Wat dit vir my beteken en hoe ek dit sien is bekendstelling van die spesifieke teleskoop . Myns insiens is dat ek nou weet van die teleskoop en indien ek sou belangstel , ek dan verder moet gaan oplees ens oor die spesifieke teleskoop.

Dit dui vir my geensins aan dat die teleskoop nou 'n goeie teleskoop is nie. Ek voel ook dat die teleskoop nie volwaardig getoets is nie, en dat jy as persoon wat hom sal wil koop , eers meer moet uitvind. Ek het gou 'n paar van die ou tydskrifte deurgegaan en kon nerens vind dat daar enige negatiewe opmerkings geskryf is oor 'n teleskoop waar iemand hom gebruik het om 'n bok te jag nie, met die toetsing van die teleskoop.

Die verslae wat in so artikel saamgevat word gee nie voldoende feite oor die betrokke teleskoop , dat 'n persoon nie verdere navorsing moet gaan doen nie.

Groetnis
JACO SWART
Rustenburg
Noord-Wes
Louis102
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 3887
Joined: Fri Dec 19, 2008 12:19 pm

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by Louis102 »

rednat wrote: ... Van ons skrywers in van ons voorste jag en geweer tydskrifte maak hulle gereeld hieraan skuldig -- ook 'n soort van soustrein??? ...
Rednat, miskien het jy 'n geldige punt beet, maar hoekom versuim jy om die "skuldige" rubriekskrywers wat so oneties optree, se name te noem?  Daar is sekerlik baie eerlike manne in die bedryf wat eerlike opinies sal gee en nie met 'n bok en 'n swak scope omgekoop kan word nie?  Almal wat nou al gevra is om 'n opinie oor 'n scope te gee, se naam is nou in gedrang, insluitend sekere lede op hierdie einste forum. 

As jy die "gutts" het om die aantyging te maak, noem sommer die naam(e) van die persoon(e) wat jy beskuldig ook.  Ons kan hulle dan vra om hulle kant van die saak ook te stel, of hoe? 

So dink ek maar.

Louis
Goeie dade oortref goeie woorde.
User avatar
tripodmvr
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 21608
Joined: Fri Mar 11, 2011 8:31 pm

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by tripodmvr »

Ek wil my bepaal by die toetse wat die forumlede doen.

Die werklike resultate word verbloem in die posting. Kan dit nie tesame met die ander toetse as 'n spreadsheet of teksdokument weergegee word wat al die pertinente eienskappe met mekaar vergelyk nie. So opsomming sal die lede in staat stel om 'n beter oorsig oor die toetsings te kry en beter besluite te kan neem rakende hul keuse vir 'n teleskoop.
.22 Krico, Howa 223 Varminter, 243 AI Musgrave RSA, Ruger RPR 243, P14 - 7 x 64, BSA 303 Sporter, 375 H&H Musgrave, 30-06 Ruger No. 1A, Khan O/U 12br, Norinco O/U 12br
User avatar
Gerhard
Hero Member
Hero Member
Posts: 7128
Joined: Sun Apr 12, 2009 6:08 pm

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by Gerhard »

Nikon het perseel verskuif vanaf Midrand Centurion toe die afgelope week....

As alles goed gaan sal ek my teleskoop die komende week kry en dan so gou as moontlik begin terugvoering gee.

Ek het gister aand met die 3 - 10 x 50 Burris op die Hornet geskiet en ons het 3 jakkalse in die koue om.

Toe ons vanoggend op pak (01:00) het die ryp/ys op die bakkie se dak gel?...  :o
FFF Safaris
Battlefields of the Escarpment
rednat

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by rednat »

Louis
Ek het miskien so bietjie meer guts as wat jy wil glo. Om op die forum aan sensitiewe sake te raak is reeds genoeg bewys van guts -- ons weet tog hoe sensitief sekere van ons kan reageer.

My doel was nie om nou name op die swartbord te skryf - nee. Maar wel om die, vir my en blykbaar ook vir andere, onaanvaarbare praktyk onder lede se aandag te bring sodat sodanige kamstige praktiese jagevaluasies in die toekoms deur lede ge?dentifiseer sal word as onvoldoende onaanvaarbaar en vir wat dit werklik is.
Jou stelling
Almal wat nou al gevra is om 'n opinie oor 'n scope te gee, se naam is nou in gedrang, insluitend sekere lede op hierdie einste forum.
Ag nee man -- hoe kom jy nou daarby uit. JY onderskat beslis toetentaal die intelligensie van forum lede. As daar wel 'n lid is vir wie die skoen pas dan moet hy hom maar met plesier aantrek. Ek het egter nie aan forum lede skoene uitgedeel nie -- die paar evaluasies soos bv. Piet sn wat ek wel gelees het was objektief en hoe jy hulle nou onder verdenking wil plaas weet nugter alleen.
Louis102
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 3887
Joined: Fri Dec 19, 2008 12:19 pm

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by Louis102 »

rednat wrote: ... Ek het miskien so bietjie meer guts as wat jy wil glo ...
Rednat

Nee, maar dan is ek bly as jy meer "gutts" as wat ek wil glo, maar die omvang van jou dapperheid is nie wat my gepla het nie.  Die punt wat ek wou maak, is dat 'n storie meestal twee kante het.  Alhoewel ek s? dat jou argument geldig klink, sou ek tog graag die "beskuldigde(s)" wou uitnooi om hulle kant van die saak te stel.  Dis egter duidelik dat my voorstel nie by jou byval vind nie, so laat dit daar.

Mooiloop
Louis

Ns.  So, behalwe vir Piet Breedt, beskuldig jy nou ook nie vir Koos Barnard, Tafjak, Gerhard en/of Francois Marais van omkoopbaarheid en swak etiek nie?  Verstaan ek jou reg?  Van hierdie manne se integriteit is reeds deur van ons Forum-lede in twyfel getrek, sou jy dit dalk nie weet nie.  Daarom dat ek graag met jou wil uitklaar, wat presies dit is, wat jy s?.
Goeie dade oortref goeie woorde.
User avatar
Hein M.
Hero Member
Hero Member
Posts: 3887
Joined: Wed Mar 25, 2009 3:52 pm

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by Hein M. »

Almal

Die teleskoop- toetsings wat op hierdie forum weergegee is, is volgens my mening uitstekend.  99.9% Van alle rubrieke in jagtydskrifte is ook aanvaarbaar en toets die produk omvattend.  Ek waardeer ook die ouens wat bereid is om na vore te kom en bereid is om die produkte te toets.  Dit sal 'n bonus wees as hierdie praktyk kan uitbrei na allerlei jagtoerusting - veral dit wat deur die Suid-Afrikaanse geleentheidsjagters gebruik word - min van ons het kennis en maak maar staat op dit wat ons lees en hoor van slim verkoopsmanne. 

Hein
Nie alles wat getel kan word, tel nie. En nie alles wat tel kan getel word nie. - Albert Einstein
rednat

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by rednat »

Louis
Ag nee. In jou naskrif is jy nou sommer doodeenvoudig moedswillig en dit pas nie by jou normale bydraes nie. Het daardie manne wie jy nou by name noem hul miskien wel aan my beweerde ongewensde praktyk skuldig gemaak?? -- anders is dit mos jyself wat hulle nou ywerig 'n etiket aangehang het.
Louis102
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 3887
Joined: Fri Dec 19, 2008 12:19 pm

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by Louis102 »

rednat wrote: ... In jou naskrif is jy nou sommer doodeenvoudig moedswillig en dit pas nie by jou normale bydraes nie ...
Rednat

Kyk gerus wat Francois Marais (Reply 85) van hierdie topic s?:
Francois Marais wrote: .....Met so n tikkie hartseer dat ek hierdie moet post...die manne reken dat as iemand iets verniet kry om te hou, dis nou ek en Gerhard en die NIKON scopes, sal ons nie in staat wees om ons eerlike menings te gee tov die scopes nie en bevooroordeeld wees....
http://jaracal.com/http://jaracal.com/p ... 169#p69169

Ek wou verkeerde persepsies wat mag ontstaan, uit die weg ruim, maar is my fut is uit om verder hieroor te redeneer.

Mooiloop
Louis

Ns.  Alles in rooi is na die tyd bygesit, besluit maar self of jou beskuldiging / belediging geldig is.
Last edited by Louis102 on Mon Jun 27, 2011 12:24 am, edited 1 time in total.
Goeie dade oortref goeie woorde.
User avatar
Piet Breedt
Hero Member
Hero Member
Posts: 2275
Joined: Mon Mar 15, 2010 10:54 am

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by Piet Breedt »

tripodmvr wrote: Ek wil my bepaal by die toetse wat die forumlede doen.

Die werklike resultate word verbloem in die posting. Kan dit nie tesame met die ander toetse as 'n spreadsheet of teksdokument weergegee word wat al die pertinente eienskappe met mekaar vergelyk nie. So opsomming sal die lede in staat stel om 'n beter oorsig oor die toetsings te kry en beter besluite te kan neem rakende hul keuse vir 'n teleskoop.
Tripodmvr, verduidelik watter werklikke resultate verbloem word?, ek verstaan jou stelling nie mooi nie?

Jy moet ook in ag neem dat ons elkeen 1 x teleskoop gekry het om te toets, en nie n hele spul van verskillende fabrikate om sy aan sy te toets. Ons toets wat ons sien, en vergelyk dit maar met ons eie scopes en met ander waarmee ons ervaring het.
.
rednat

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by rednat »

Asb. Kom ons los die katte se gatte!!!

As iemand 'n scope toets het ek geen probleem daarmee nie en wag ek met belangstellende afwagting op die verslag.
As iemand 'n scope as geskenk ontvang vir die moeite om dit te toets of andersins hinder dit my ook nie en gun ek hom dit.
As hy 'n objektiewe en vollediige evaluering doen verwelkom ek dit en lees ek dit met belangstelling en met waardering.
As hy 'n niksseggende evaluering doen identifiseer ek dit as sulks met teleurstelling.
AS daar egter spesiaal 'n jag bekom word net omdat die teleskoop dan nou kwansuis net op 'n wildsbok getoets moet word dan het ek wel 'n probleem. Die blote sommernet doodskiet van 'n bok is geen regverdigbare toets vir 'n teleskoop nie en is werklik niksseggend. Jy kan enige teleskoop beter en meer volledig toets in praktiese nagebootste omstandighede. As jy wel 'n jag het en dan na jou evaluering die teleskoop en geweer daarvoor gebruik, geen probleem. Nou wat het ek oorspronklik ges? vootdat die kat se gat vasgegryp is: Net dit:
Dan word 'n gratis doodmaak geleentheid by 'n jagplaas verkry met die voordeel van advertensieruimte -- en dan moet 'n bok doodgeskiet word om nou kwansuis die geweer of teleskoop te toets --- die geweer of teleskoop kon net so goed of selfs beter op 'n teiken getoets word.
As iemand daarmee 'n probleem het het ons verskillende waardes en moet ek dit so aanvaar.

Piet
Die toets van 'n teleskoop verg sekerlik 'n doelgerigte beplande benadering soos jy reeds bewys het. Wil jy en jou ander evalueerders nie so 'n norm saamstel waarvolgens evaluering gedoen en beoordeel moet word nie. Dit kan dan as riglyn help dat ons in die toekoms objektiwiteit verseker.
User avatar
Piet Breedt
Hero Member
Hero Member
Posts: 2275
Joined: Mon Mar 15, 2010 10:54 am

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by Piet Breedt »

Vir die van julle wat moontlik tweifel in die opregtheid van die bedoelings van hierdie toets, plaas ek die kontrak wat Gerhard en Francois moes teken vir julle om te sien. Hierby kan julle sien dat Nikon geen voorwaardes aan hulle geplaas het, anders as om die geweer vir n jaar te toets om n objektiewe en langtermyn verslag te lewer. Hulle het nie eers gevra dat ek enigsins n kontrak met hulle sluit, en het nie eers my handtekening op papier. Hulle het sowat 2 jaar gelede ook vir my n scope gegee om te toets, sonder enige voorwaardes. Ek het my eerlikke opinie van die scope aan hulle deur gegee, met dit waarvan ek nie gehou het ook daarby. As hulle nie daarvan gehou het om negatiewe dinge te hoor oor hul produk, dink enige iemand dat hulle my dan weer sou vertrou met hierdie toetse, en borgskappe van R185,000.00? Ek glo nie daaraan om net heuning om hul monde te smeer nie, bloot net omdat hulle my in hul vertroue geplaas het om hul produk te toets.


Nikon - Suid Afrika Borgskap aan Jaracal Lede


Nikon Suid Afrika onderneem om aan elk van die genomineerde skuts (twee) n Nikon  Monarch 2.5 ? 10 x 56 SF IL #4 geweer teleskoop te gee onder die volgende voorwaardes.

1. Dat ek met die Nikon geweer teleskoop  geborg deur Nikon Suid Afrika sal skiet op my jakkals geweer  in die volgende jaar. Julie 2011 ? Julie 2012 en my bevindinge sal plaas op die Jaracal Forum.

2. Indien jy  nie verder wil skiet met die Nikon produk tydens die kontrak jaar, en jy dit wil afhaal van jou geweer, jy die geweer teleskoop sal verbeur, en dit onmiddelik sal terugstuur aan PJ Breedt (Piet) wat die gevolmagtigde van Nikon Suid Afrika is met betrekking tot hierdie borg en dat hy dit dan sal aanwend op sy eie diskressie ten bate van Nikon SA.

3. Nikon onderneem ook om hulle waarborg gestand te hou ten opsigte van enige probleme met enige van hulle produkte, sou dit opduik.

4. Nadat jy die borgvoorwaardes nagekom het, word hierdie  produk jou eiendom en kan jy daarmee maak wat jy wil.

Hiermee bevestig ek......................................................... met ID nommer................................................................
en e-pos adres......................................................
en telefoon nommer............................................
Fisiese adres.........................................................
...............................................................................
dat ek die voorwaardes van die borgskap aanvaar, en onderneem om my daarby te hou.
Geteken op  20 Junie 2011





Ek dink as enige iemand al die specs op n scope wil h?, om dit te vergelyk met sy mededingers, kan hy dit gaan Google. Nie ek of een van die ander is lus om elke spec te gaan oplees en hier te plaas. Ons toets die scopes in die veld en op die baan, en plaas ons eerlikke mening daaroor hier op die forum.
Last edited by Piet Breedt on Mon Jun 27, 2011 9:58 am, edited 1 time in total.
rednat

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by rednat »

Piet
Dit is nou mooi uitgespel -- al was dit onnodig.
Ekself aanvaar beslis nie die verantwoordelikheid om  'n scope vir 2 jaar lank te toets nie -- te veel tyd en PT -- al gee hulle my ook 2 scopes as geskenk. Nee wat baie minder moeite om ander ouens se evaluerings te lees ( en te kritiseer :angel:) en sommer die regte ding wat ek wil h? te loop koop.
Het gou by google gaan inloer --- en sien toe dat die wiel in baie opsigte klaar uitgevind is.


Hein en Raychell
dit lyk mos amper of hierdie ou Dave hieronder ook weet wat hy doen??


Nikon 4x ?16x Tactical Scope
(Mil Dot Reticle)

13 April 2004
By Dave Bahde
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Introduction
Quite some time ago I had the opportunity to test a Nikon 2.5 to 10x Tactical scope. It was done at the request of a friend of mine that manages a local gun store here. I found it to be a pretty good scope. In any case I completed the review and submitted it to Sniper Country and they posted it. It was some months later that I was contacted by Steve and was asked to contact Nikon. It appears that someone actually reads what I write, because Nikon wanted to use one of my statements. As this individual was from Nikon, it was one of the good things, but hey, I was just happy someone actually read my review. Besides as second focal plane scopes go, the Nikon was a great scope. In any case I was asked to test their new 4-16 Tactical scope. I am un-accustomed to this whole process, usually I evaluate stuff I buy, but they said I could have it for the test, and just send it back. Sounded good to me, and I was curious to see if anything had changed since my last review. This has been a bit of a long term test, so I will cover a bit more than I did with the last one.

Description
When the scope arrived at the office, upon opening the box I noticed something immediately. This scope came with Butler Creek covers! Someone more important than me must have made the same complaint. In any case, as all tactical scopes should, it comes with a sun shade, and the Butler Creeks it needs. It has a 50mm objective and a 41mm ocular piece. The tube is 30mm and the overall length is 14 inches. The construction is very strong. It weighs in at 24oz, and is a very nice matt tactical color. To me the best way to describe this scope is "practical and functional". It has the same large, easy to read knobs, and is graduated in 1/4 minute adjustments. There are 10 minutes per single revolution of the scope, and the spec sheet indicates there are 50 total minutes of adjustment. I actually found there to be more usable minutes than listed in this particular scope. There is a side focus knob on the opposite side of the windage adjustment. The power settings are adjusted by turning a dial on the ocular piece. When adjusting the power settings it does not move the eyepiece however, so your Butler Creek cover will not move. It comes with an Allen wrench to adjust the knobs. This scope came equipped with the Mil-Dot Reticle. It is similar in appearance to the Premier Gen II in that it has lines in between the dots. The dots are of the round variety, and the line is at one half a Mil. This particular scope did not have a lighted reticle. If it did the rheostat would be on the eyepiece. All in all it is a very nice looking scope with good balance, and it feels substantial, as a tactical scope should.

Off of the Rifle
With this particular scope I had longer to "crank the snot" out of the knobs. I was waiting for a 300WM rifle to arrive I was having re-barreled so I had it for a couple of months before I mounted it on any rifle. As before, I moved them from the bottom to the top all the way to their limits. As I was enjoying the latest drivel on the television I would move the knobs up and down, and left and right for the entire evening. I even had a couple of my officers take the scope and do the same thing for a few weeks. All in all, the knobs were turned more than most anyone would likely do so in their real lives. The movement, and the "clicks" are very positive, and stayed positive throughout the test. They are in fact still tight to this day. When I was done moving them around I returned them to their mechanical center. In looking at the glass, it is very clear. I would place the clarity somewhere between the U.S. Optics, and the Nightforce NXS scope. In moving between the power settings it is very smooth. I would prefer they not be as close, but it is easy to adjust, and it stays in position. I like to have a little more space between the settings, but it is very positive, so it is not likely it would move in the bag. As this reticle is in the second focal plane, it stays consistent throughout the power range. It comes equipped with an adjustment for us "old folks", so the reticle is clear as well. Lastly, in using the focus knob it is large, easy to grab and smooth.



Nikon 4x ?16x Tactical Scope (Mil Dot Reticle), showing ocular and turrets


The Rifle Roundup
This scope showed up when I was in somewhat of a state of flux with my collection of precision rifles. I was about to receive my 300WM back from Robar. I also had a 338LM and was about to try a 300WSM rifle as well. This particular scope was mounted, and re-mounted several times. It finally ended up on my loaner FNSPR in .308 caliber. The SPR is the rifle the scope was on when I performed the final test for elevation and windage.

Mounting
In every case the scope mounted easily, and was long enough to mount on the long actions. One of the long actions was a Remington 700, the other is a CZ550 Magnum in 338LM. It was mounted in some Badger Ordnance rings (except the CZ). On all but the CZ the base was a Badger or OPSII one-piece base with a 20MOA slope.

Zeroing
This particular scope performed pretty well in this arena. On all but the last rifle it would print on an 8.5 x 11 sheet of paper, even though the rifles were different caliber. On the last rifle it printed pretty much dead center, but it was quite a bit off to the right. It had been a couple of months since it had been on a rifle so it may have been moved. In any case, initial zero with this scope was pretty easy every time I changed rifles. As on the 2-10 the knobs are about as secure as you get. There are four set screws per knob, so they won't go anywhere for sure. One word pretty well describes my experience with this scope. That word is repeatable. Once you zeroed the scope, the thing stayed put, and it put them in the same spot. In fact, I found myself using this scope to test what I thought may be problems with other scopes, or the rifle. I had some issues with a NXS scope I was trying to use. It would not hold its zero. I would set it up, shoot a group, and it would print a pretty good group. I would re-load, and it would shoot another group in a different spot. It was a new rifle so I thought it may be the rifle. Just for kicks, I put the Nikon back on it. I had actually used the Nikon to break that rifle in. I mounted it in the same spot, fired the group, and it was within half an inch of the original zero. I fired several groups, all of them in the same spot. I sent the Nightforce back to the factory for repair. Throughout this test, this scope was on a Remington 700 in 300WM that had an 18.5 inch barrel with a suppressor, a GAP 338LM on a CZ550 Magnum Action, a GAP M1A, that same Remington only re-barreled with a 24" K and P tube, an FNSPR in 300WSM and finally the FNSPR in .308 caliber. This scope has been around, and on every gun it zeroed easily, and stayed on zero. It is as repeatable as any other scope I have ever had.

Adjustments
I put together a new process when it comes to checking the adjustments on these scopes I evaluate. I borrowed a target that a good friend of mine (Bob Schneider) put together for his sub-machinegun classes. It has a series of circles on it that are equidistant, and lends itself very well to checking a scope. I have inserted a picture so you can see it. The drill is fired all at once, so it has the scope moving in all kinds of combinations, at the extremes of the elevation and windage adjustments. It starts with a confirming zero on a separate target, and ends with a zero on the same target. The true measure is where it impacts, relative to zero, after all that turning.


The target includes the following tests.
A kind of "rectangle" drill that measures 24 MOA of windage and 10MOA of elevation.

A standard box drill that has 5 MOA of windage, and 10MOA of elevation.

A windage drill that moves from zero to 10MOA either direction.

And lastly a drill that moves from zero, down 5MOA and up in 5MOA increments to a total of 35MOA yielding a total of 40MOA in elevation adjustments.

Target used for scope testing


Why did I do this, and what were the results?
Just so there is no confusion, I am not certain all this knob turning means all that much, but it seems to be what people want when you test a scope. I still determine what elevation is needed in my scope at a particular range the old fashioned way, I shoot it, at that range. It seems nowadays the computer is taking over, and people want their scopes to match their calculators. I am not saying that is a bad thing, just not my thing. The first time someone told me that their scope adjustments were wrong, because they did not measure "precisely .25MOA I about fell over". My response was "who cares, so long as you know where to put the knob, and it hits in the same spot every time, well "there ya go!". What is most important to me is that it is repeatable, meaning it does the same thing every time. Whether that "thing" is .25 MOA or .2513365 MOA is meaningless to me, as long as you know your gun. But hey, I am kind of old fashioned that way. In any case, in my humble opinion, nobody is going to do what I did to this scope in real life. Most people just do not have this kind of time. Lucky for me, I can work this into my weekly training. In any case take these for what you think they are worth. What I think this test does show, is how repeatable the scope is, and whether it will return to zero when you turn the knobs. The drill is performed in the order I will describe them below. I listed kind of a synopsis of the drill. If you want to send me an e-mail I will send out the exact measurements of each shot. Please remember a human is performing this drill, from prone, with a bi-pod. Truth is you can probably attribute at least .25 inch to the shooter at any given time. Once again, take them for what they are worth.

Zero
The first thing I do is establish a good solid zero for the drill. The purpose is to establish the ability of the scope, not the cold bore. I set up a separate target, and shoot a three shot group. I continue that process until it is grouping in the center of a .75" square at 100 yards. Once that is done, I start the drill.

Windage
This drill starts at the orange dot on the target. I fire the first shot there. I then add 4L, then 6L totaling 10 MOA left. I fire a second shot without change, then move 6R, 4R and return to zero. I then perform the same drill moving to the right, and returning to zero.


Left Windage: Each shot was within .25 of inches of an exact measurement.
Right WIndage: Each shot was within .25 inches of an exact measurement.

Results: This scope is pretty much right on. Several of the repeat shots as it returned to zero are in the same hole. Two of the three shots at zero were in the same hole.

Elevation Drill
This drill starts at the number 12 circle on the left. In order to simulate those that actually enter down elevation, I hold the target on the first shot, and put in 5D. I then return it to zero and fire on the circle. I then add 5U, firing at each change until I have added 35 MOA of total elevation in the scope. I then return back down the scale to the starting point doing the same thing.

The results of this drill are pretty typical. Accept for the last 5 MOA of adjustment everything was either at exactly 5" or within a .25 inch. The final adjustment, at the top of the knob was 5.75 inches. In most of these scopes, as the knobs get closer to their limits they tend to be less precise.

Results: Once again this scope is showing pretty strong repeatability. Including the movement down, the spread between shots was almost exactly 5" on every shot. The only one that was a little wide, was at the limits of the knob. With a .308 this shows a total of 40" of elevation, which should take most anyone out to 1000 yards, and it seems to be pretty consistent.

Box Drill Wide
This drill is kind of out there, but if you want to test the limits, this one put in 24 MOA of wind in your scope, with 10MOA of elevation. I figured this would show any glaring errors.

24MOA Left: The movement from zero to the left was off the target to the left. It measured about 27" where it nicked the cardboard.

10MOA Up: When I moved it up it impacted 26.5" left and at 10.25 inches up.

24 MOA Right : On this shot it moved 24" almost exactly.

10MOA Down: This shot moved 10" down and impacted right next to the starting shot.

Results: Three inches difference at 100 yards would be substantial. Once again this is pretty out there, so as you get closer to the limits things are less precise. In terms of reality, I suppose if you were putting 24 MOA of wind in your scope you are kind of pressing your luck! In any case this was the only drill where this scope was not pretty consistent.

Box Drill Tall
This is more of a normal box drill, and is more in line with what you may actually put into your scope. The zero on this drill is the number 6 on the right side of the target. The drill moves 4L ? 5U ? 5U ? 4R ? 5D ? 5D. Each measurement was within 1/16th of an inch, and the return to center was about in the same hole.

Results: This drill was the last drill, after all of the knob turning, and it was about the cleanest. The measurements were about as exact as I can get, and the return to the start was right on.

Return to Zero
With the scope returned to zero, I fired one shot on the separate target. It impacted .5 right and .25 high in comparison to the starting shot. Pretty close concerning the knob turning, and what amounts to a 40 round drill.

Real Usage

The Nikon 4x - 16x mounted on a rifle
Prior to testing the scope in that last drill I used this scope extensively on the range. I fired a number of cold bore shots, and it was fired out to 400 yards. I had a number of people use the scope, and they all complimented the glass, and the positive clicks. It held the cold bore as well as any scope.

Conclusions
This particular scope is plenty rugged, and in fact is more rugged than most any of the scopes out there in the same price range. I personally would take this scope over any Leupold, or any Nightforce scope. I think this is the market they are headed for, and they do a pretty fine job. It is more money than the Leupold, but it is flat out more scope. The glass is better, the knobs are better, and it has held up better than any Leupold I have ever owned. It is at least on a par with the Nightforce everywhere except elevation, and it is LESS money. I have seen these scopes in the low $800.00 range. The glass is very clear, and the side focus works well throughout the entire range. I like scopes that change the power setting without moving the ocular piece. It is a pain in the rear to have your Butler Creek's move every time you change power settings. If you are into exposed target knobs you will like these. They are big, and certainly secure. Once you lock them down there should be no issues with losing your zero. They now provide the necessary Butler Creeks, and the sunshade. With a 20MOA base this scope as it sits will get you out to 1000 yards with a .308 or bigger. This is a really solid entry into the market.

The things I don't like about this scope are pretty much the same as the 2-10 power. There are only 10 minutes per revolution. That is one place where the Nightforce kind of rules. Performing that drill was a pain, and I had to really stay on my toes not to get lost. I know it makes for the big knobs and all, but if you are into long range there will be lots of turning. The eye relief once again puts the scope kind of close. It is close, and not forgiving. It is easy to move just a little and end up with scope shadow. On the magnums, there were a couple of close calls. I would appreciate a little more eye relief, and a little more forgiveness in acquiring it. The last thing is the need for some elevation. It is right at the limits of most calibers. It indicates in the literature there is 50 MOA, but this scope from top to bottom has 70MOA. I did not take the time to determine when the "run out" starts, but I would bet there is about 60 or so minutes of usable elevation. As long as you are mounting this on a bolt gun, with a sloped base, and it is close to the bore, you are fine. If you are mounting this on an AR10 there will be some issues. Mounted on the rifle in the picture I am only 2.5 turns from the bottom. You are going to lose at least 10MOA just getting that scope zeroed on an AR10. There really needs to be closer to 75MOA of usable elevation. I am not sure if they can do that, but it would certainly broaden the market a bit.

Last Thoughts
Once again, this is an excellent scope. It is priced to compete with the Leupold offerings, and it competes very well. If you want a similar design, and you are not married to Leupold this would be an excellent alternative. It is also in the price range of the Nightforce NXS scope, but it is coming down. You can get into a Nikon for around $800.00 and that is about two bills cheaper than the NXS. It is as rugged as the NXS, in fact the only two NXS scopes I ever had failed very quickly. They had great customer service, but when it comes to my tactical scopes I would prefer to not need it! It is as clear as the NXS, but with Leopold-like features. With all of the changes in the Leupold line, and some of their price increases they are getting very close to the Nikon. It is ending up right in the middle of the pack. Just be certain of your shooting needs so you do not run out of elevation, but this is a fine scope, and more than capable of a duty environment.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Last edited by rednat on Mon Jun 27, 2011 5:54 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Hein M.
Hero Member
Hero Member
Posts: 3887
Joined: Wed Mar 25, 2009 3:52 pm

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by Hein M. »

Piet Breedt wrote:
Nie ek of een van die ander is lus om elke spec te gaan oplees en hier te plaas. Ons toets die scopes in die veld en op die baan, en plaas ons eerlikke mening daaroor hier op die forum.
Piet,

Dit is wat ons waardeer.

Kom ons HOOP die post word nie weer gekaap nie 8)  Ek hoop die onweerswolke het so 'n bietjie weggetrek.

Ons sien uit na die volgende Nikon-nuus!

Groetnis!

Hein
Nie alles wat getel kan word, tel nie. En nie alles wat tel kan getel word nie. - Albert Einstein
User avatar
tripodmvr
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 21608
Joined: Fri Mar 11, 2011 8:31 pm

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by tripodmvr »

Piet Breedt wrote:
tripodmvr wrote: Ek wil my bepaal by die toetse wat die forumlede doen.

Die werklike resultate word verbloem in die posting. Kan dit nie tesame met die ander toetse as 'n spreadsheet of teksdokument weergegee word wat al die pertinente eienskappe met mekaar vergelyk nie. So opsomming sal die lede in staat stel om 'n beter oorsig oor die toetsings te kry en beter besluite te kan neem rakende hul keuse vir 'n teleskoop.
Tripodmvr, verduidelik watter werklikke resultate verbloem word?, ek verstaan jou stelling nie mooi nie?

Jy moet ook in ag neem dat ons elkeen 1 x teleskoop gekry het om te toets, en nie n hele spul van verskillende fabrikate om sy aan sy te toets. Ons toets wat ons sien, en vergelyk dit maar met ons eie scopes en met ander waarmee ons ervaring het.
.
Jammer lanklaas hierna geloer. My voorstel is dat jul finale verslae op 'n aparte plek gepost word sodat dit nie tussen al die kommentaar verdwyn nie. Ek hoef dus nie daarvoor te soek nie.
.22 Krico, Howa 223 Varminter, 243 AI Musgrave RSA, Ruger RPR 243, P14 - 7 x 64, BSA 303 Sporter, 375 H&H Musgrave, 30-06 Ruger No. 1A, Khan O/U 12br, Norinco O/U 12br
projag

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by projag »

Hein M
99.9% Van alle rubrieke in jagtydskrifte is ook aanvaarbaar en toets die produk omvattend.
JY lees dus alle jagtydskrifte om so 'n stelling te kan maak?? En vind dus 99.9% van alle toetse en evaluasies, soos bv. ook in SA JAGTER/HUNTER,  vir jouself aanvaarbaar en omvattend??? Het jy ook die SA JAGTER van Junie 2011 gelees en vind jy die toets en evaluasie soos daarin vervat omvattend en bevredigend??
Ek verbeel my dat daar gedurende die jagseisoen van 2010 en voorheen ook oor verskeie ander toetse verslag gedoen is in die SA JAGTER --  het jy dit ook 99.9% omvattend en aanvaarbaar gevind??

Skynbaar is daar 'n ernstige meningsverskil oor wat omvattend en aanvaarbaar is as dit kom by die toets van jagtoerusting. Miskien kan iemand probeer om riglyne daar te stel wat aan die behoeftes van die meerderheid voldoen. Wat soek die meerderheid in 'n evaluasie  -- 'n vergelykende konsekwente evaluasie of 'n promosie verslag.
User avatar
Hein M.
Hero Member
Hero Member
Posts: 3887
Joined: Wed Mar 25, 2009 3:52 pm

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by Hein M. »

???

Die 99.9% uitdrukking is by wyse van spreke.  As jy 'n Proleser is soos ek, sal jy weet wat dit beteken ;)

As jy werklik 'n probleem met die evaluasies in daardie tydskrif het - en dit lyk my jy het een - skryf vir die redakteur 'n brief en noem dit vir hom.  Ons kan niks daaraan doen nie.

Dankie vir jou inset ;D

Hein
Nie alles wat getel kan word, tel nie. En nie alles wat tel kan getel word nie. - Albert Einstein
Beretta
Hero Member
Hero Member
Posts: 2954
Joined: Wed May 06, 2009 4:09 pm

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by Beretta »

Jislaaik Hein lyk my jy is nie n oom nie jy kan nog goed lees en tik die artirtus het jou nog nie kom vat nie daar in jou blyplek nie ;D ;D ;D ;D
Beretta
User avatar
tripodmvr
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 21608
Joined: Fri Mar 11, 2011 8:31 pm

Re: Nikon toetsing

Post by tripodmvr »

Hein M. wrote: ???

Die 99.9% uitdrukking is by wyse van spreke.  As jy 'n Proleser is soos ek, sal jy weet wat dit beteken ;)

As jy werklik 'n probleem met die evaluasies in daardie tydskrif het - en dit lyk my jy het een - skryf vir die redakteur 'n brief en noem dit vir hom.  Ons kan niks daaraan doen nie.

Dankie vir jou inset ;D

Hein

Sien my vorige post net bietjie boontoe. Daar is soveel skrywes dat jul kommentaar verswelg word. Daarom my versoek dat jul opsommings onder 'n aparte "skoon" post geplaas word wat nie oop is vir kommentaar.

Ek voel ook dat kommentaar wat afwyk van die tema na 'n ander gespreksforum verskuif moet word.

.22 Krico, Howa 223 Varminter, 243 AI Musgrave RSA, Ruger RPR 243, P14 - 7 x 64, BSA 303 Sporter, 375 H&H Musgrave, 30-06 Ruger No. 1A, Khan O/U 12br, Norinco O/U 12br
Post Reply